- Egg Nog
- Rum Raisin
- Black Raspberry
- Maple Walnut
- Strawberry Banana Froz Yogurt
- Pink Grapefruit Sherbet
- Peppermint Stick
- Vanilla M&M
All Rennell's ice cream is homemade. We have 30 standard flavors and rotate about 12 flavors of ice cream, frozen yogurts, and sorbets every week.
MaryAnne has an amazing flavor sense and makes all the flavors, including the extraordinary Vanilla Bean. People tell us "it tastes like the vanilla when I was a kid."
Jeff and MaryAnne started this vision with this philosophy: A family of four (being reasonable!) should be able to visit our ice cream shop for about $10.
Jeff retired from teaching high school in 2008. MaryAnne would not let him stay home. In February, while sitting by the woodstove eating ice cream, MaryAnne said, "Let's start an ice cream shop." The dream was born. And here we are: Extraordinary ice cream at a reasonable price.
We carry the traditional flavorites of vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. The rest of our flavors change daily and seasonally. We also have ice cream cakes and pints ready to go.
People have enjoyed our Cookie Dough, Red Raspberry Chocolate Chip, Almond Yippee, Black Raspbery, Almond Yippee, Coconut, Coffee Fudge Almond, Maple Walnut, Strawberry Yogurt, Lemon Sorbet, Vanilla Caramel Swirl, Double Mint Chocolate Chip, Pumpkin Pie (fall/winter), Eggnog (winter), and more! Be sure to call ahead to see if we have your favorite flavor that day.
We accept cash and personal checks. We are located in the center of Bethlehem, right next to the Colonial Theatre.
Kids ... 2.00
Small ... 2.50
Medium ... 3.00
Large ... 3.50
Chocolate & Rainbow Jimmies ... Free
One topping, whipped cream + cherry
Small ... 3.55
Large ... 4.25
AdditionalToppings ... 1.00
Hot fudge, Caramel, Strawberry, Marshmellow, Peanut Butter, Pineapple
Walnuts, Pecans and Peanuts ... 50¢
Made with soft serve and swirled
with one add-in ... 3.90
Extras ... 50¢
Butterfingers, Reeses Pieces, Oreo, Skittles, Heath Bar, Bubble Gum, M&Ms, Gummi Bears, Nestles Crunch Pieces, Snickers, Reeses Peanut Butter Cups
Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Coffee ... 4.15
Malt ... + 25¢
9% tax is included in all prices.